Wednesday, 30. June 2010 15:23
Here is a list of my picks for TOP BC Red Wines as of this date. This in an overall list and each wine was not only put into perspective of their overall quality but also in terms of the value they offer in respect of other BC and international wines.
#1 8th Generation 2008 Merlot - Tom in our Duncan store brought this to my attention and I am forever grateful. We tasted shortly after I arrived back from Argentina where I had tasted through a lot WOW factor wines that would land on our shelves between $17-$30. In other words I lifted the glass with the thought that there was no way this wine was going to wow me.
The nose features ripe and red plums, blueberries and hints of black pepper spice. As the aromas tail off there is a delicious and enticing hint of fresh ground coffee and dark chocolate. The nose immediately compared to a number of California, Washington State, Western Australia and Patagonian (Argentina) wines that I had recently tasted.
The palate was rich and full and it carried through the mid-palate right through the finish. This was not a donut wine as I have experienced with a few premium BC Merlots recently. The berry and plum flavours came through nicely. The spice and coffee tones also showed themselves gracefully but on the finish mostly. What really told the story of this wine to me was how the complexity unfurled itself slowly at first and then in waves with each successive taste.
After being suitably impressed and having a number of wines in my head that I thought it would compete with on a quality level, came the question that often depresses a wines score- what’s the price man? With Tom’s answer the wines score actually rose in my mind. I truly felt that this wine actually over delivered for the price and will be on my shopping list this Canada Day weekend
Price: $23.99 +deposit
Availability: good; but once this order is sold there will be no more.
Score: 7.8/$1
Competitors: This is a list of other wines from other places in the world that I felt this wine compares with or performs better than. Benziger Merlot (Ca. $29.99) Casa Lapostolle Cuvee Alexnadre Merlot (Chile $29.99) J Lohr Merlot (Ca. $22.99) Mollydooker Merlot (Aus. $35.99) St. Francis Merlot (Ca. $34.99) Sterling Estate Merlot (Ca. $27.99)
#2Starling Lane 2008 Marechal Foch – I have to say that this was the dark horse that I didn’t see coming up. If it was just a couple of bucks less it would have been my number 1 for sure. What really made this such a surprise is that it is made right here on Vancouver Island and that it is Marechal Foch. After first release of the Quail’s Gate Foch in the early 90’s there have been a lot of players but not many that could combine depth, complexity, acidity and avoid some of the ‘awkward’ flavours that can come through with this variety.
The nose is heaping with black plum and ripe red raspberry with highlights of violets and lavender floating over top. In fact it immediately made me think of top end Carmenere out of the Chile, Uco Valley Malbec from Argentina, and even some Barbera D’Asti from Piedmonte, Italy.
The power and the grace of this wine came on the palate. It is a big full bodied mouthful of juicy goodness. I had the bottle with friends over about a 3 hour period and it continued to wow the whole time through.
Price: $26.99
Availability: Very limited – total of maybe 10 12 bottle cases in stores for this vintage
Score: 7.5/$1
Compare to: Sebastiani Barbera (Ca. $36.98) La Spinetta Barbera D’Asti Di Piane (Italy $39.99) La Joya Carmenere Reserve (Chile $25.02) Alfiero Boffa Barbera (Italy $34.99)
#3 Mission Hill Reserve 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon – Now here is a BC wine that if placed in a blind tasting with a number of California or Coonawara Cabernet Sauvignons and not only would it show well, it would surprise a number of people that it came from BC.
The grapes sourced for this wine are from select blocks of select old vine vineyards in the Okanagan Valley and this care in the vineyard shows through in spades.
The nose greets you with red currants and red berry fruits, a touch of dark cocao and just a hint of mint reminiscent of some Cabernet driven Bordeaux’s that are priced in the $40 range.
The palate is big and juicy and, again, if you didn’t know any better you would swear it was from California. The finish is long and juicy with some dried herbs.
Price: $21.99 +deposit
Availability: Good; we should be in stock 90% of the year.
Score: 7.3/%1
Compares with: J Lohr Cabernet Sauvignon (Cal. $22.99), Liberty School Cabernet Sauvignon (Cal. $23.99 ) Rodney Strong Cabernet Sauvignon (Cal. $22.99 ) Catena Cabernet Sauvignon (Argentina $22.99), Edge Cabernet Sauvignon (Cal. $33.99).
#4 Young & Wyse Merlot- The former winemaker at Burrowing Owl, Stephen Wyse, set up his own project with his partner Michelle Young to produce some bold BC reds.
The nose is full of sweet raspberry & cherry fruits with a touch of mint, vanilla and dark cocoa. The palate carries the crushed berry essence of this wine right through the finish which offers some delicate vanilla and cocoa flavours. A great buy and one of the best in this price range from BC.
Price: $24.99 +deposit
Availability: Total of 1000 cases made and only a few left with the next vintage not due to hit the shelves until later 2010 or early 2011.
Score: 7.3/$1
Compares with: Burrowing Owl Merlot (BC $34.99) Casa Lapostolle Cuvee Alexnadre Merlot (Chile $29.99) Road 13 Rockpile (BC $24.99) Sterling Estate Merlot (Ca. $27.99)
#5 Tinhorn Creek 2007 Cabernet Franc- Cabernet Franc is, in my opinion, our, BC’s, best red grape. We grow a lot of Merlot, Pinot Noir, Cabernet Sauvigon and Shiraz, but the quality offerings are in very short supply. On the other hand Cabernet Franc seems to be available in decent quantity and in pretty damn good quality. It is just that people are not as familiar with it. Let’s make that change.
Cabernet Franc is by nature, an aromatic grape that features cherry, sour cherry, red currants and some floral characters. This wine has these aromas in spades with the bonus of a touch of vanilla on the finish.
The palate is soft and sultry and at first impression you would think that you are tasting a Chianti Classico or even a Nebbiolo. The Tinhorn Creek is a juicy, rich and well balanced offering that goes down very, very smoothly.
Price: $18.99 +deposit
Availability: New vintage just released so there should be no problems unless… unless people really understand how good this wine is.
Score: 7.4/$1
Compares to: Peppoli Chianti Classico (Italy $28.99) Carpinento Chianti Classico (Italy $21.99) Peller Estate Private Reserve Cabernet Franc (BC $19.99) Sandhill Cabernet Franc (BC $19.99), Sumac Ridge Black Sage Cabernet Franc (BC $19.99