WINE TALK: Too much information!
Tuesday, 17. August 2010 21:00
When is too much information too much information? I wish I knew where that tipping point was especially when it comes to wine, wine, beer & ciders.
In order to scientifically determine the tipping point I set out with my family last week. There are 11 in total of which 6 were of legal drinking age and I believe that makes a quorum although perhaps not a statistically relevant survey pool.
I was well armed and had 6 different Pinot Grigio’s and one Gavi. Of the Pinot Grigio’s 4 were Italian, 1 Californian and one from BC.
One night, after the kids were in bed I held the experiment. My methodology was simple. Use the same wines in three different scenarios and measure the results.
First, without showcasing the labels I asked them to taste each wine and asked them to rank the wines in order of preference. I tried to insure that this round was not about the wine, rather I wanted it to be about which wine made the occasion better so I kept talking about ‘stuff’. Everyone joined in insuring that this was about the occasion, much like a dinner party or wedding would be.
The second round of tasting was of the same wines but I messed up the order and spoke in detail about each one insuring that I had the floor the whole time. I started with region, then vintage, then grape or blend, viticultural practices, then winemaking technique, my own description of the wine in terms of colour, aromas, flavour and finish, and finally price. This time it was about the wine in every detail and not about the label or occasion.
The third round I once again messed up the order but this time showed the labels but didn’t utter a word. They were free to make their preferences known. This round was about how the label and price of each wine and the effects these factors had on the enjoyment.
What I found out is that the more the environment is about enjoyment and not about the wine the greater the appeal of juicier easy to drink wines.
The more the focus in on the practical elements of the wines the enjoyment was heavily influenced by the description. In fact the favourite in the first round, the Castellani Pinot Grigio Ramato, came last in the second round when I described the wine in detail. Fascinating as this wine had a ton of details that enthralled me.. the cork dork of the group.
The third round showed something very interesting. No one wine came out on top, rather each person’s favourite was the they wine whose label spoke to them the most.
Lastly I brought out some cheeses and other nibblies and said have at it. The first bottle to be finished was the Castellani Pinot Grigio Ramato, followed closely by the Arrowleaf Pinot Gris and San Silvestro Gavi.
The only conclusion is simple: enjoy your family, your food and your wine and you will have a higher quality of life… one sip at a time.
Thema: New Releases, Wine Talk, wine | Kommentare (2) | Autor: admin











